| Pick | Team | Player | Pos |
| 1.01 | Pittsburgh | Maris,Roger* | CF |
| 1.02 | Washington | Pappas,Milt | P |
| 1.03 | Philadelphia | Osteen,Claude* | P |
| 1.04 | Chicago | O'Dell,Billy# | P |
| 1.05 | Detroit | Pizarro,Juan* | P |
| 1.06 | Kansas City | Podres,Johnny* | P |
| 1.07 | St. Louis | Kubek,Tony* | SS |
| 1.08 | Cleveland | Held,Woodie | CF |
| 1.09 | New York Giants | Cardwell,Don | P |
| 1.10 | Boston | Purkey,Bob | P |
| 1.11 | Baltimore | Shaw,Bob | P |
| 1.12 | Brooklyn | Drott,Dick | P |
| 1.13 | Cincinnati | Jay,Joey# | P |
| 1.14 | Chicago | McMahon,Don | P |
| 2.01 | Kansas City | Roseboro,Johnny* | C |
| 2.02 | Pittsburgh | Landis,Jim | RF |
| 2.03 | Washington | Kasko,Eddie | 3B |
| 2.04 | Detroit | Miller,Bob L | P |
| 2.05 | Chicago | Nixon,Russ* | C |
| 2.06 | Philadelphia | Latman,Barry | P |
| 2.07 | St. Louis | Gentile,Jim* | 1B |
| 2.08 | Cleveland | Hobbie,Glen | P |
| 2.09 | New York Giants | Green,Lenny* | CF |
| 2.10 | Boston | Elston,Don | P |
| 2.11 | Baltimore | Duren,Ryne | P |
| 2.12 | Brooklyn | Schult,Art | 1B |
| 2.13 | Cincinnati | Neeman,Cal | C |
| 2.14 | New York Yankees | Daniels,Bennie* | P |
| 3.01 | Pittsburgh | Anderson,Bob | P |
| 3.02 | Kansas City | Lee,Don | P |
| 3.03 | Washington | Sawatski,Carl* | C |
| 3.04 | Detroit | Anderson,Harry* | LF |
| 3.05 | Chicago | Bolger,Jim | CF |
| 3.06 | Philadelphia | Aspromonte,Ken | 2B |
| 3.07 | St. Louis | Green,Gene | RF |
| 3.08 | Cleveland | Brown,Dick | C |
| 3.09 | New York Giants | McDevitt,Danny* | P |
| 3.10 | Boston | Thomas,Valmy | C |
| 3.11 | Baltimore | Hazle,Bob* | RF |
| 3.12 | Brooklyn | Speake,Bob* | CF |
| 3.13 | Cincinnati | Barclay,Curt | P |
| 3.14 | New York Yankees | Kemmerer,Russ | P |
| 4.01 | Kansas City | Hyde,Dick | P |
| 4.02 | Pittsburgh | Portocarrero,Arnie | P |
| 4.03 | Washington | Urban,Jack | P |
| 4.04 | Detroit | Walker,Jerry# | P |
| 4.05 | Chicago | Muffett,Billy | P |
| 4.06 | Philadelphia | McDaniel,Von | P |
| 4.07 | St. Louis | Cheney,Tom | P |
| 4.08 | Cleveland | Rodgers,Andre | SS |
| 4.09 | New York Giants | Morehead,Seth* | P |
| 4.10 | Boston | Mejias,Roman | RF |
| 4.11 | Baltimore | Raines,Larry | 3B |
| 4.12 | Brooklyn | Swanson,Red | P |
| 4.13 | Cincinnati | Tsitouris,John | P |
| 4.14 | New York Yankees | Becquer,Julio* | 1B |
| 5.01 | Pittsburgh | Burnside,Pete | P |
| 5.02 | Kansas City | Thomas,George | 3B |
| 5.03 | Washington | Usher,Bob | CF |
| 5.04 | Detroit | Cicotte,Al | P |
| 5.05 | Chicago | Smith,Bob | P |
| 5.06 | Philadelphia | Douglas,Whammy | P |
| 5.07 | St. Louis | Hook,Jay* | P |
| 5.08 | Cleveland | Wall,Murray | P |
| 5.09 | New York Giants | Smith,Bobby Gene | CF |
| 5.10 | Boston | Porter,Jay | RF |
| 5.11 | Baltimore | Peterson,Hardy | C |
| 5.12 | Brooklyn | Sanchez,Raul | P |
| 5.13 | Cincinnati | Boros,Steve | 3B |
| 5.14 | New York Yankees | Will,Bob* | CF |
| 6.01 | Kansas City | Smith,Paul* | RF |
| 6.02 | Pittsburgh | Tomanek,Dick* | P |
| 6.03 | Washington | Pavletich,Don | P |
| 6.04 | Detroit | Witt,George | P |
| 6.05 | Chicago | Martyn,Bob* | RF |
| 6.06 | Philadelphia | Merritt,Lloyd | P |
| 6.07 | St. Louis | Phillips,Taylor* | P |
| 6.08 | Cleveland | Pignatano,Joe | C |
| 6.09 | New York Giants | Chrisley,Neil* | RF |
| 6.10 | Boston | Rand,Dick | C |
| 6.11 | Baltimore | Constable,Jim# | P |
| 6.12 | Brooklyn | Ceccarelli,Art | P |
| 6.13 | Cincinnati | Landrum,Don* | CF |
| 6.14 | New York Yankees | Martin,Morrie* | P |
| 7.01 | Pittsburgh | Kindall,Jerry | 2B |
| 7.02 | Kansas City | Zauchin,Norm | 1B |
| 7.03 | New York Yankees | Paine,Phil | P |
| 7.04 | Detroit | Pitula,Stan | P |
| 7.05 | Chicago | Lonnett,Joe | C |
| 7.06 | Philadelphia | Bolling,Milt | 2B |
| 7.07 | St. Louis | Throneberry,Faye* | CF |
| 7.08 | Cleveland | Massa,Gordon* | C |
| 7.09 | New York Giants | Graff,Milt* | 2B |
| 7.10 | Boston | Pisoni,Jim | CF |
| 7.11 | Baltimore | Pendleton,Jim | RF |
| 7.12 | Brooklyn | Minarcin,Rudy | P |
| 7.13 | Cincinnati | Harrell,Billy | SS |
| 7.14 | New York Yankees | Taylor,Joe | LF |
| 8.01 | Kansas City | Hamlin,Ken | SS |
| 8.02 | Pittsburgh | Goryl,Johnny | 3B |
| 8.03 | Washington | Derrington,Jim* | P |
| 8.04 | Detroit | skip | |
| 8.05 | Chicago | Roach,Mel | 2B |
| 8.06 | Philadelphia | Jackson,Ron | 1B |
| 8.07 | St. Louis | Hernandez,Evelio | P |
| 8.08 | Cleveland | Pyburn,Jim | CF |
| 8.09 | New York Giants | McDonald,Jim | P |
| 8.10 | Boston | Singleton,Elmer | P |
| 8.11 | Baltimore | Westrum,Wes | C |
| 8.12 | Brooklyn | Harmon,Chuck | LF |
| 8.13 | Cincinnati | Sullivan,Haywood | C |
| 8.14 | New York Yankees | Jones,Nippy | 1B |